The bait shack at the end of Merry Pier has been empty for more than two years. At 801 Pass-a-Grille Way, near Eighth Avenue on the bay side of the island, the dock still sends out fishing charters, and for years it was also the departure point for the shuttle to Shell Key. Since mid-October, the city has approved a scaled-down rebuild of the shack and put the pier's remaining charter on a month-to-month deal. City staff also reported that the shuttle had been sold and would leave the pier, and commissioners heard from a regional planning agency that the pier could someday serve as a ferry stop.
Each of these decisions keeps the city's options open. That matters most this season to anyone who used Merry Pier as their way to Shell Key.
The bait shack is coming back on a smaller budget
The rebuild has already been scaled down once. On January 1, 2026, the Tampa Bay Times reported that commissioners had voted unanimously to restore the 123-year-old shack, even though it has no historic designation and isn't eligible for one. The Times also reported the first estimate for a rebuild that meets current code: $210,682 before design and permitting, against $82,121 in insurance coverage. Commissioners sent staff back to find a cheaper plan.
According to Bay News 9, the project stalled when later estimates topped $150,000. That ran into both the budget and FEMA's 50% rule, which can trigger current flood-resistance requirements once repair costs reach half of a structure's value. Commissioner Jon Maldonado, whose district includes Pass-a-Grille, described the new plan to the station as four walls, a bathroom and an air conditioner if possible.
In October, commissioners approved an $80,137 contract with Intellisite Inc. Public Services Director Camden Mills estimated about six months of work, including 90 days of construction. Mills expects the shack to reopen by next September, which would be September 2027.
The approved contract comes in at well under half of January's code-compliant estimate. The city chose a bare-bones version of the shack, built while bigger questions about the pier stay open.
The pier's businesses are on short terms now
The same caution shows up in how the city is handling the pier's businesses. On October 27, commissioners voted 4–1 to let Offshore Hustler Fishing Charters keep its boat slip on a temporary, month-to-month agreement at $700 per month while the city prepares to look for longer-term tenants. Offshore Hustler lists Merry Pier as its home port and runs bottom-fishing and trolling charters for up to six passengers.
At the same meeting, city staff said Shell Key Shuttle had recently been sold and would be leaving the property. For years, that shuttle was the simplest way for Pass-a-Grille residents to reach the preserve. You walked out to the pier, paid for a round trip and were dropped on a barrier island with no road to it.
The neighbors on Pass-a-Grille Way are paying attention. Cheryl Engels, who owns Island Life Pass-a-Grille, told Hoodline that her shop saw more foot traffic when the bait shack was open and that she expects the reopening to bring fishermen back to the street. In the same article, angler Jun Pagaduan pointed to the planned restroom and to being able to buy bait at the pier again.
This season, the trip to Shell Key starts in Tierra Verde
With the shuttle expected to leave Merry Pier, the boats and kayaks that serve Shell Key are now concentrated a few miles south, around Fort De Soto and Tierra Verde. Shell Key Preserve covers about 1,800 acres and can only be reached by boat. Visitors are limited to the public-use areas at the north and south ends, and the conservation core in the middle is closed.
| Option | Departs from | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Hubbard's Marina Shell Key ferry | Fort De Soto boat ramp, Fort De Soto Park, 3500 Pinellas Bayway South | Ferry to the preserve |
| Island Ferry dolphin and snorkel trip | Tierra Verde Marina Resort, 198 Madonna Blvd. | Two-hour trip, listed at $64 per person |
| Island Ferry guided kayak trips | 2962 Pinellas Bayway South | Guided paddle to Shell Key |
| Get Up and Go Kayaking | Billy's Stone Crab, 1 Collany Road | Daytime and nighttime clear-kayak tours |
| Fort De Soto kayak rentals | Fort De Soto Park | Rentals through the park's concessions operator |
If you paddle on your own, the Pinellas Bayway kayak and SUP launch is about 1.5 miles from the preserve's south public-use area, mostly through protected shallows. The Friends of Shell Key launch guide also lists the Fort De Soto boat ramp and Pass-a-Grille beach as starting points. Fort De Soto also has an 800-foot boat launch and a 2.25-mile recreational canoe trail if you'd rather stay off open water.
The Pinellas County preserve page lists the rules, and they're the same whichever way you arrive. Dogs and alcohol aren't allowed. All plants and animals are protected, and you can't remove live animals. Overnight camping in the southern public-use area requires a permit.
Why the city is keeping the pier flexible
Short-term leases and a bare-bones shack make more sense next to the third item from that October 27 meeting. Representatives from Forward Pinellas, the county's transportation planning agency, told commissioners that Merry Pier could serve as a hub for ferry service linking communities along Gulf Boulevard. Nousheen Rahman, a principal planner with the agency, said Mayor Scott Tate had raised interest in a ferry several weeks earlier. "Identifying a hub is probably a really key step," she told the commission.
St. Pete Catalyst reported that the idea is still only an idea. No routes, operator, funding or schedule were announced, and commissioners took no action. Forward Pinellas has added waterborne transportation to its long-range transportation plan, which a project needs before it can be considered for future transportation funding. The agency's recommendations for St. Pete Beach include looking at publicly owned docks and working with neighboring barrier island communities.
There are working ferries elsewhere in the area to compare it with. The Clearwater Ferry has connected downtown Clearwater, Clearwater Beach and Dunedin since 2015, and Rahman said it received about $655,000 in state transportation funding to move from on-demand trips to scheduled departures. The Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority is also preparing to launch the Tampa Bay Ferry between downtown St. Petersburg and Tampa before the end of 2026, with Hubbard's Marina as the operator.
A ferry would bring back one of the pier's earliest uses. The Florida Division of Historical Resources marker and the Catalyst's account give the outline:
- 1902. Joseph E. Merry opens a store at the end of the Eighth Avenue dock, selling bait, groceries and tools and renting boats.
- 1905. Ferries are carrying passengers to the fishing village.
- Until 1919. Pass-a-Grille can only be reached by water.
- 2022. The city finishes a major reconstruction with new decking, pilings, utility connections and lighting.
- 2024. Helene and Milton damage the property again.
Within a few years of Merry's store opening, the pier was already a passenger landing. A city that may turn it back into one has good reason not to sign long leases or build a large shack before it knows.
What to expect on Pass-a-Grille Way this winter
Through the winter, the scaled-down bait shack will move through its roughly six-month project, with the city projecting a September 2027 reopening. Offshore Hustler's slip will stay month to month. Any ferry plan depends on partnerships, destinations and an operating plan that the city hasn't put together yet. Merry Pier isn't the only Pass-a-Grille landmark on a long timeline. Pinellas County lists design work on the Gulf Beaches Historical Museum at 115 10th Ave. as not yet started, with design running from fall 2026 to spring 2028 and construction from spring 2028 to spring 2029.
If a Shell Key day is on your winter list, the most direct way to get there this season starts at Fort De Soto or Tierra Verde. Merry Pier is still where to go for a fishing charter.
If you live near Pass-a-Grille Way and want to talk through what the pier's next few years could mean for your street, or you're thinking about a home where the bay and the boat schedules are part of daily life, I'm glad to walk through it with you. Casey Franks. Let's Connect.